Illustration of a person standing at the beginning of a winding path that stretches into the distance, surrounded by lush, green mountains and trees. The sky is bright with fluffy clouds, giving the scene a sense of adventure and possibility. The person appears to be ready to embark on a journey.

Crafting Unforgettable Arcs: Create Captivating Characters

Reading Time: 19 minutes
Incredible character arcs show transformation. Characters evolve in ways that resonate as they confront challenges. Their journeys leave a lasting impact, making stories remarkable.

In fiction, crafting unforgettable character arcs is essential for creating engaging stories that resonate deeply with readers. Plot progression and transformational scenes that create convincing characters create compelling story arcs. In previous posts, I discussed why it’s essential to master character development (briefly explaining how evolving character arcs drive the plot forward) and to craft compelling conversations between characters to create persuasive literature.

Photograph of Belinda D'Alessandro. Belinda is wearing a red jacket over a red dress and a string of pearls. She is standing in front of windows with shutters
Belinda D’Alessandro

Imagine reading a story where you truly care about the characters—where their hopes, fears, and mistakes feel real. That’s the magic of a strong character arc. When a writer gives their characters genuine motivations, clear goals, and believable flaws, it’s much easier for readers to connect and root for them. The journey isn’t just about what happens next; it’s about how the character grows, struggles, and changes along the way.

Think of a character’s arc as the emotional heartbeat of the story. It’s shaped by moments of doubt, bursts of courage, and those big turning points where everything shifts. By focusing on these elements, how a character feels, what drives them, and how they wrestle with their own inner battles, writers can create stories that don’t just entertain but truly move us. The most memorable scenes are often those in which a character faces a challenge and emerges transformed, leaving us inspired and eager to see what happens next.

So, let’s explore key storytelling tools and narrative techniques that enhance character development and plot progression through effective character arcs.

The Heartbeat of Every Great Story

Think about your favourite stories, the ones that stick with you long after you’ve finished reading. What makes them so unforgettable? It’s often the way the characters change and grow. A character’s journey isn’t just about what happens to them; it’s about how they wrestle with challenges, face their fears, and discover new sides of themselves.

These arcs are the heartbeat of a great story. They help us care about the characters, root for them, and see a bit of ourselves in their struggles and triumphs. When a character’s growth feels real, it pulls us in and makes the whole story come alive.

Why Character Arcs Matter

An open notebook on a wooden desk, surrounded by scattered papers and writing tools. On one page, there’s a hand-drawn portrait of a character, with notes and thought bubbles detailing the character’s traits, motivations, and background. The other page contains written reflections and questions about the character’s journey.Character arcs are essential for creating narratives that resonate with readers: narratives where you find yourself cheering for the characters, feeling their struggles, and celebrating their victories. That’s the power of a great character arc. It’s not just about what happens in the plot, but about how the characters grow and change along the way.

When we see a character face challenges and come out the other side transformed, it feels real and meaningful. That journey is what draws us in and makes us care. When writers focus on this kind of growth, their characters become people we remember long after the story ends.

Practical Narrative Techniques

There are practical narrative techniques and growth strategies that can help refine your writing. Understanding the structure of character arcs, such as turning points and emotional beats, is fundamental to compelling storytelling.

If you want your stories to really connect with readers, it helps to think about your characters as real people who change and grow. Start by asking yourself: What drives them? What do they care about, and what’s at stake if they fail? As your characters move through the story, let them face challenges that force them to make tough choices: these are the moments that shape who they become.

Don’t rush their growth. Instead, let it unfold naturally through key moments, those turning points where everything changes, or scenes where a character finally faces their fears. These are the parts of the story that stick with us, because we see the character’s journey as genuine and relatable. When you focus on what motivates your characters and show how they change over time, your readers will feel that transformation right alongside them.

Resonating with Your Audience

Exploring how a well-defined character arc can resonate profoundly with your audience is not just a structural component of storytelling: it’s key to successful storytelling and to engaging your audience.

Characters who confront challenges, undergo internal conflict, and ultimately transform are captivating to readers: they become relatable figures who embody the complexities of human experience.

By crafting arcs that reflect real-life struggles and triumphs, you can create a narrative that not only entertains but also inspires. The emotional connection forged through character growth is what makes stories unforgettable.

The journey of transformation a character undergoes, whether it’s a shift in perspective, growth in strength, or overcoming personal fears, captivates readers and invites them to invest in the characters’ journeys. This investment is crucial; as audiences witness the evolution of characters, they inevitably reflect on their own lives, drawing parallels that enrich their understanding of the story and themselves.

Making Characters Unforgettable

By crafting arcs that effectively encapsulate real-life struggles, setbacks, and victories, storytellers can weave narratives that transcend mere entertainment; instead, they serve as inspiration, teaching valuable lessons about resilience and the human spirit.

A small plant sprout emerging from rich, dark soil. The background is softly blurred with shades of green, drawing attention to the delicate new leaf and the seed casing still attached to the stem.The emotional connection established through character growth deepens a story’s impact. When a character successfully navigates their trials, the resulting transformation resonates deeply with readers.

This is not just about seeing a character succeed; it’s about experiencing their hardships alongside them and feeling camaraderie and empathy. Such connections lead to stories that linger in the minds and hearts of audiences long after the final page is turned. The universality of these emotional experiences is what makes a narrative unforgettable, capable of eliciting laughter, tears, and a deep sense of understanding.

The significance of a well-defined character arc extends beyond narrative structure; it is a crucial element that enhances the storytelling experience by fostering genuine connections between characters and readers. Through thoughtful and deliberate character development, authors can craft stories that resonate on multiple levels, ultimately leaving a lasting impact that inspires and moves their audience.

Understanding the Power of Character Arcs: More Than Just Change

Character arcs are essential elements of storytelling that go beyond mere change; they capture a character’s profound journey from beginning to end. A well-crafted character arc enriches the character and enhances the overall plot, creating a more engaging experience for readers.

Defining Character Arcs

A character arc refers to the evolution of a character throughout a story, showcasing their growth, challenges, and ultimate transformation. An emotional arc often mirrors this journey, examining the character’s internal struggles and feelings. Together, these arcs create a compelling narrative that echoes with readers, allowing them to connect deeply with the characters and their experiences.

A complex character arc shows how a character changes over the course of a story: the struggles they face, the ways they grow, and who they become by the end. A character’s development is not merely a linear progression; instead, it encompasses the myriad ways in which the character reacts to both external circumstances and internal dilemmas.

Each encounter pushes the character in a new direction, sparking moments of self-discovery and personal revelation that enrich the overall storytelling experience.

Defining Emotional Arcs

Similarly, an emotional arc often closely mirrors the external character arc, digging deeper into the nuanced internal struggles and complex feelings the character must grapple with. This emotional journey invites readers to explore the character’s inner world, shedding light on their fears, desires, hopes, and regrets.

For instance, a character might begin the story confident but gradually confront profound insecurities that challenge their self-perception and worldview. The interplay between these inner conflicts and the character’s external choices is critical, as it emphasises the interplay between who they are on the outside and what they experience on the inside.

Together, these arcs collectively create a compelling narrative fabric that resonates deeply with readers, forging connections that extend beyond the mere plot. Through the lens of character and emotional development, audiences can find echoes of their own experiences in the struggles and triumphs portrayed.

This dynamic relationship between characters and readers enhances engagement and fosters empathy, allowing readers to walk alongside the characters as they navigate the intricate tapestry of life, confront adversity, and ultimately evolve into stronger versions of themselves.

The integration of character and emotional arcs is essential in crafting a rich, multifaceted story. By exploring how characters grow and change in response to their challenges and their emotional landscape, authors can create narratives that are not only captivating but also profoundly humane, enabling readers to gain insight into the complexities of the human experience.

The Importance of Character Growth in Plot Progression

Character growth is fundamental for powerful plot progression. It moves the story beyond mere events and actions, allowing readers to invest emotionally in the characters’ journeys. When characters face obstacles and evolve, it creates a dynamic narrative that keeps readers engaged, eager to see how they will respond to challenges and what choices they will make.

When characters encounter significant challenges, whether they are external conflicts with other characters, internal struggles with their own beliefs or emotions, or even situational dilemmas that test their morals and values, they are often faced with pivotal decisions that shape their futures.

This process of grappling with hardships and making consequential choices not only adds depth to the characters themselves but also enriches the plot, as readers become increasingly eager to see how they will respond under pressure.

The emotional stakes are raised when characters are put to the test; readers form attachments and rooting interests, eager to see which direction they will take. For example, a character who begins their journey with a rigid mindset may find themselves questioning their beliefs as they meet new allies or face dire straits, leading to a transformation that resonates powerfully with the audience. This evolved character can serve as a reflection of human experiences, illustrating themes of resilience, redemption, and the complexity of personal growth.

The Interplay Between Character Growth and Plot Development

Man in a fedora and trench coat walks down a city street at night.The relationship between character growth and plot development is essential in keeping readers engaged. As transformations occur within the characters, the narrative shifts, creating new avenues for conflict and resolution that intrigue the audience.

Readers become invested not just in the plot’s outcome, but also in the individual arcs of the characters: they become emotionally entwined, sharing in their triumphs as well as their failures.

This engagement fosters anticipation: readers are likely to ponder what lessons the characters will learn, how these experiences will affect their relationships, and who they will ultimately become.

Character growth is not merely an interesting element of storytelling; it is a vital force that enhances a narrative’s emotional resonance and propels the plot forward. It invites readers into a deeper connection with the characters’ journeys, fostering empathy and understanding that can leave a lasting impression long after the story concludes.

This dynamic interplay of character evolution and plot progression transforms a simple tale into a rich and compelling saga that lingers in readers’ minds and hearts.

Internal vs. External Story Arcs

Understanding the distinction between internal and external story arcs is crucial for compelling storytelling. Internal conflict serves as the powerful engine driving genuine change within a character.

While external arcs may focus on physical challenges or plot points, internal arcs delve into the character’s motivations, fears, and desires, making their journey more relatable and impactful.

Understanding the distinction between internal and external story arcs is crucial for compelling storytelling, as it significantly contributes to how an audience connects with the narrative and its characters.

Story arcs form the backbone of storytelling, guiding the trajectory of both plot and character development. Internal conflict emerges as a powerful engine driving genuine change within a character, often resulting in profound transformations that resonate with viewers or readers.

While external arcs typically centre on physical challenges faced by the characters, such as battles, quests, or other tangible obstacles, internal arcs dive deeper, exploring the emotional landscapes of the characters. These arcs focus on the motivations that propel characters forward, the fears that hold them back, and the deep-seated desires that inform their actions and decisions throughout the story. By examining these internal struggles, storytelling becomes more nuanced and layered, allowing the audience to engage with characters on a more personal level.

Interplay Between Internal and External Arcs

This interplay between internal and external story arcs not only enriches the narrative but also enhances the relational aspect of the journey. For instance, when characters confront their fears or grapple with their desires, they often emerge more relatable and complex. This complexity makes their journey resonate more deeply with the audience, fostering empathy and understanding—qualities essential to meaningful storytelling. The emotional stakes of internal conflicts compel audiences to invest in the characters’ journeys, cheering their successes and mourning their failures.

So, recognising and effectively utilising both internal and external story arcs is essential for crafting a compelling narrative. By balancing thrilling external adventures with profound internal growth, storytellers can create a rich tapestry of experiences that elevate their stories beyond mere entertainment, making them powerful explorations of the human experience.

The Role of a Clear Character Arc

A clear character arc provides your story with purpose and direction, making it feel complete and satisfying. It allows readers to witness the character’s growth and understand the stakes involved in their journey. By establishing a well-defined arc structure, you can guide your readers through the narrative, ensuring that each turning point and story beat contributes to the character’s development.

A clear character arc serves as a crucial element in storytelling, providing not only purpose but also direction to your narrative, ultimately making it feel complete and satisfying to the reader. When a character evolves, the audience can witness this transformation firsthand, gaining insight into the emotional and psychological stakes of their journey.

This progression is not merely a series of events; rather, it reflects the character’s internal struggles and triumphs, making their experiences resonate on a deeper level. Establishing a well-defined arc structure is essential for guiding your readers through the narrative effectively. It helps to lay out a roadmap outlining the character’s path, including their struggles, challenges, and milestones.

Turning Points Serving Purpose

Each turning point and story beat you incorporate should serve a specific purpose, contributing to the character’s overall development. For instance, consider the moments of conflict where the character must confront their fears or make difficult choices; these are pivotal in demonstrating how much they have grown.

Besides, a well-crafted character arc engages readers by allowing them to invest emotionally in the character’s journey. As readers follow the ups and downs, they become more connected to the character, rooting for them during hard times and celebrating their victories. This engagement reinforces the notion that the stakes are high, whether in personal relationships, moral dilemmas, or heroic endeavours, making the character’s growth more impactful.

A thoughtfully designed character arc enriches the storytelling experience by engaging the audience in a meaningful way. It offers a clear trajectory for both the character and the story, ensuring that the development is not only coherent but also compelling. By weaving together the intricacies of the character’s journey with the overarching narrative structure, you can create a story that feels cohesive, fulfilling, and ultimately rewarding for your readers.

Character arcs are not just about change; they are about the journey of growth and transformation that resonates with readers. By understanding and implementing effective character development strategies, you can create memorable characters that leave a lasting impact on your audience.

Navigating the Landscape of Character Arc Types

Character arcs are essential storytelling tools that shape your characters’ journeys and, ultimately, the narrative itself. Understanding the different types of character arcs — positive, negative, and flat — can significantly influence how your story resonates with readers. Each arc type serves a unique narrative purpose and contributes to the thematic depth of your work.

Common Arc Structure Types

Character arcs can generally be categorised into three main types: positive, negative, and flat. Understanding these categories is crucial for writers and readers alike, as they provide a framework for analysing character development and a story’s emotional journey. Each type offers a distinct perspective on how characters transform, or don’t transform, throughout the course of the narrative.

Infographic of character arc types
🌱 Positive Arc
- Character grows, learns, or transforms in a meaningful way
- Overcomes internal flaws, fears, or limiting beliefs
- Faces external challenges that push them toward change
- Ends in empowerment, fulfilment, or redemption
- Resonates because it mirrors real human growth and hope
⚠️ Negative Arc
- Character declines morally, emotionally, or psychologically
- Begins with potential or good intentions but makes destructive choices
- Internal flaws deepen rather than resolve
- Often ends in tragedy, loss, or corruption
- Functions as a cautionary tale about consequences and unresolved conflict
🧭 Flat Arc
- Character remains fundamentally the same throughout the story
- Holds a strong belief or truth that influences others
- Acts as a stabilising force or catalyst for change in supporting characters
- Often plays mentor, guide, or moral anchor roles
- Provides contrast to characters undergoing growth or decline
Character Arc Types

The Positive Arc

A positive arc typically involves a character growing and changing, often overcoming internal conflicts and achieving their goals. This kind of arc often sees the character overcoming internal conflicts, such as insecurities or personal limitations, while also navigating external challenges that threaten their goals.

For example, a character who begins as shy and hesitant may learn to embrace their own strengths through various trials and tribulations. This arc resonates with readers, as it reflects the potential for personal development and redemption.

Readers are frequently drawn to these characters because their journeys mirror the real-life experiences of growth and transformation that many individuals aspire to achieve. Such arcs not only illustrate triumph over adversity, but they also inspire audiences by showcasing the resilience of the human spirit.

The Negative Arc

In contrast, a negative arc depicts a character’s decline, often culminating in tragic or disastrous outcomes. This type can evoke strong emotional responses, highlighting the consequences of poor choices or unresolved conflicts.

For instance, a character might begin with noble intentions but gradually succumb to greed or corruption, ultimately leading to their downfall. This descent can serve as a cautionary tale, illustrating how a single decision can set off a chain of events that irrevocably alter one’s life.

Negative arcs remind readers of the fragility of human morality and the devastating impact that unresolved issues can have on an individual’s path.

The Flat Arc

Lastly, flat arcs feature characters who remain essentially unchanged throughout the story. While they may not undergo significant personal growth, these characters can still play pivotal roles in the overarching narrative.

They can serve as anchors for other characters, providing stability and consistency amid change or chaos. For example, a wise mentor figure may stay steadfast in their beliefs while guiding a more dynamic character through their transformative journey.

Also, flat arcs can often act as catalysts for change in others, highlighting how their own traits or actions can influence those around them. Even without personal evolution, these characters possess depth and purpose, enriching the story by providing a contrast to the more malleable characters who experience growth or decline.

The three types of character arcs—positive, negative, and flat—each offer unique avenues for storytelling and character exploration. They allow for a range of emotional engagement, from inspiration and hope to caution and concern, ultimately creating a more nuanced understanding of the human experience as presented in literature.

Whether characters are evolving, descending, or remaining steady, their journeys are integral to the narrative’s themes and messages, engaging readers and prompting reflection on their own lives.

Choosing the Right Story Arc Type

When deciding which character arc to employ, consider the specific narrative scenarios and overarching themes you wish to explore. A positive arc may be ideal for stories centred on hope and resilience, while a negative arc could suit tales that delve into the darker aspects of human nature.

Flat arcs can be compelling in stories that focus on external events rather than character development, allowing for a more straightforward narrative progression. A well-chosen character arc can significantly enhance the emotional resonance and depth of your narrative, so careful consideration is warranted.

Storyboard-style diagram illustrating a character’s narrative arc. The layout features six connected boxes arranged horizontally, each containing distorted or placeholder text resembling a creative writing framework. Some phrases are highlighted in yellow, suggesting emphasis on key story beats. The final box at the bottom reads “Character athe transformative journey,” indicating a focus on character development. Arrows link the boxes to show progression, though the text is largely nonsensical. The overall design implies a conceptual flowchart for storytelling or character transformation.For example, if your story centres on themes of hope, resilience, or personal growth, a positive character arc may be the most fitting choice. This type of arc typically involves the character embarking on a journey of transformation, evolving from a state of vulnerability or despair to one of strength and empowerment.

By illustrating how characters confront and overcome obstacles, you can effectively convey powerful messages about the human spirit and the possibility of redemption, inspiring your audience along the way.

On the other hand, if your narrative more closely examines the darker aspects of human nature or the complexities of moral ambiguity, a negative character arc may be more appropriate. This arc usually depicts a character’s descent into moral chaos or various forms of self-destruction, showcasing how they may lose their way as they confront their innermost flaws and desires.

Such arcs can provide a sobering lens through which to examine human behaviour, encouraging readers to reflect on the consequences of choices made in the face of adversity and temptation.

Also, flat character arcs can be particularly effective in narratives that prioritise external events over personal character development. In stories characterised by intense action or significant plot-driven events, flat arcs allow a straightforward narrative progression in which characters remain consistent and unchanged amid the swirling dynamics around them.

This can help maintain focus on the unfolding plot or thematic messages without diverting attention to internal conflicts, creating a satisfying and engaging experience for the audience. Ultimately, the choice of character arc should align with the specific needs of your story and the emotional journey you want your readers to embark on.

By thoughtfully considering these elements, you can craft a character arc that enriches your narrative and resonates deeply with your audience, drawing them into the world you’ve created.

The Role of Static Characters

Static characters, or those who do not undergo significant change, can still contribute to memorable growth within the story’s ecosystem. Their steadfastness can provide stability and contrast against dynamic characters, highlighting the latter’s transformations.

A person dressed in a long, flowing cloak standing among rocky mountains and wildflowers, holding a book. The sky is filled with dramatic, golden clouds, and the landscape stretches out into the distance, bathed in warm light.For instance, a static mentor figure can illuminate the protagonist’s journey and offer wisdom and guidance while remaining unchanged. This interplay can enrich the narrative and deepen reader engagement.

Static characters, individuals in a narrative who do not undergo significant transformation or evolution over the course of the story, can nevertheless play a crucial role in fostering a sense of memorable growth within the broader ecosystem of the plot and its characters.

Their unwavering nature provides a stabilising force that can serve as a critical contrast to the dynamic characters undergoing significant changes in their personal arcs. This contrast is not only valuable but also necessary, as it accentuates the transformations and developments of the dynamic characters by offering a steady point of reference against which their growth can be measured.

For example, consider the presence of a static mentor figure within a storyline. This mentor might be an elderly sage or a seasoned professional, someone who possesses a wealth of knowledge and life experience. Throughout the narrative, this character remains unchanged, clinging consistently to their values, beliefs, and principles.

Their role is paramount; they illuminate the protagonist’s journey by providing essential wisdom and guidance, serving as a beacon of stability amid the often tumultuous experiences the main character faces.

Static Characters Can Highlight Development

A static character’s consistent demeanour and steadfast nature not only reinforce the message they convey but also highlight the protagonist’s development by standing in stark contrast to the protagonist’s changes.

When readers observe the protagonist evolving in response to the challenges and trials presented, the mentor’s unyielding presence underscores the significance of that growth. It emphasises how far the protagonist has come, showcasing the shifting landscape of their personality and beliefs when juxtaposed with the mentor’s static character.

This dynamic interplay between static and dynamic characters can significantly enrich the narrative, offering deeper layers of meaning and insight for the audience. It invites readers to engage more fully with the story, encouraging them to reflect not only on the characters’ transformative journeys but also on the foundational traits of those who remain constant.

As a result, the tension and interaction between these contrasting character types can evoke a more profound emotional response from the reader, fostering greater engagement and investment in the unfolding narrative. By weaving the steadfastness of static characters together with the vibrant evolution of dynamic ones, a richer, more compelling tapestry of storytelling is created, one that resonates deeply with the audience.

Impact on Reader Perception

The choice of character arc significantly shapes readers’ perceptions and the narrative’s overall message. A well-crafted positive arc can inspire and uplift, while a negative arc may provoke reflection on the consequences of choices.

The positive arc can encourage readers to empathise with the character’s journey and perhaps even see reflections of their own lives in it. Such arcs often feature a protagonist who undergoes significant growth, learning valuable lessons along the way. A character who starts out self-absorbed might eventually understand the importance of community and caring for others, thereby embodying themes of redemption and personal development.

Conversely, a negative character arc can provoke deep self-reflection among the audience, forcing them to confront the often harsh realities of decision-making and the consequences of those choices. This kind of arc often centres on protagonists who descend into failure or moral ambiguity, prompting readers to grapple with questions of ethics and the unpredictability of life.

A character who consistently makes poor choices despite warnings may evoke sympathy and frustration, prompting readers to consider which behaviours lead to detrimental outcomes.

An open book with warm, glowing light illuminating its pages. The book is open to a section of text, and the surrounding atmosphere feels magical and inviting, with tiny golden sparks or particles floating above the pages.

Flat arcs, though less dynamic, can still evoke strong connections through their interactions with other characters. A flat arc typically denotes a character who does not undergo significant internal change but instead serves as a stabilising force or a catalyst for change in those around them. Through their consistent values and beliefs, these characters can illuminate others’ flaws and transformations, creating a compelling dynamic that enhances the narrative’s depth.

Think of a character like a mentor who embodies wisdom and integrity; their presence might inspire others to act decisively or courageously, thereby providing a contrasting backdrop against which the growth of other characters can be highlighted.

Understanding how these varied character arcs influence readers’ emotions and engagement can substantially enhance your ability to craft a more compelling, resonant story. By thoughtfully considering how each character’s journey affects the reader’s emotional experience, you can better design your narrative to provoke the desired responses.

By weaving the complexities of these arcs together, you not only enrich the plot but also ensure that your message resonates deeply with your audience, allowing them to walk away with a profound sense of connection to the story and its characters. This, ultimately, is the essence of effective storytelling.

At the End of the Day

Crafting unforgettable character arcs is about creating people your audience can genuinely connect with. When you slow down and dig into who your characters are — what drives them, what scares them, what they long for — you start turning simple sketches into fully realised individuals who come alive on the page.

Strong arcs grow out of meaningful plot moments, the scenes where something shifts for the character and their journey takes a new direction. Those turning points are what keep audiences hooked, because they can feel the character changing in real time.

Think about how powerful it is to watch a character move from uncertainty or conflict toward clarity, strength, or understanding. Every step of that journey gives you a chance to show their growth.

Audiences get to sit with them through the messy parts, celebrate the wins, and feel the weight of the setbacks. That emotional investment is what makes people root for a character’s success, or their redemption, and what makes their story linger long after it’s over.

Final Thoughts

Crafting unforgettable character arcs is at the heart of powerful storytelling. By focusing on authentic growth, emotional journeys, and meaningful challenges, writers can create characters who truly resonate with readers.

Whether your story follows a path of transformation, explores the consequences of choices, or highlights steadfast figures, the journey your characters take will leave a lasting impression. When you invest in their development and let their struggles and triumphs unfold naturally, you invite your audience to connect, reflect, and be inspired — making your stories memorable long after the final page is turned.

I’d love to know which fictional character is your favourite and the specific qualities or traits that make them stand out in your memory. Together, let’s explore the nuances of storytelling and the powerful dynamics of character arcs!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *